Keane Criticizes Robertson: All Talk, Scotland Never Threatened Germany

In their opening match of the 2024 Euros, the Scottish national team suffered a crushing 1-5 defeat to Germany, a result that sparked a strong reaction from former Manchester United star Roy Keane, particularly towards Scotland’s captain Andrew Robertson’s post-match comments.

The passionate Scottish fan base, reportedly comprising 4% of the country’s population, traveled to Munich in support, but their cheers were drowned out by the home team’s dominant performance at the Allianz Arena. Goals from Wirtz, Musiala, and Havertz in the first half gave Germany a commanding 3-0 lead, with Ryan Porteous’ red card for Scotland compounding their woes, leading to a 5-1 victory for the Germans.

After the match, Liverpool defender Robertson attempted to analyze the defeat: “In the first half, we got almost everything wrong. We didn’t show the urgency or positivity needed, allowing their top players too much control. With ten men in the second half, the lads did give it their all. It’s disappointing in front of such a massive support. We need to bounce back quickly because there are clear issues that need addressing. Perhaps this is a wake-up call, reminding us how tough these games can be.”

However, Keane, working as an ITV commentator, was unimpressed with Robertson’s assessment: “Andy Robertson talks about having a ‘game plan,’ which is fine, but then he says ‘we weren’t positive enough.’ In football, being proactive is a basic requirement, especially against stronger opponents. You need to show aggression. I agree, you appreciate the skill on display, and Germany were impressive tonight. But at this level, you have to stand up and be counted, engage positively. To retreat like Scotland did tonight… talking about a ‘plan’ after the game… that’s just talk! Andy Robertson, that’s just talk. The importance of the game should’ve been understood before kickoff, and talking about ‘rebuilding’ and being ‘angry tomorrow’ doesn’t cut it.

“No, you should be angry long-term. We talked about making history, and you did make history… just not in the way you wanted, letting down the manager and all the supporters. That penalty foul wasn’t aggression; it was foolishness. Being aggressive in the game is crucial, but you never threatened Germany at all.”